An example, not your letter

Linda is 63. Her daughter stopped speaking to her two years ago. Nothing on this page comes from your answers, and nothing you have written has been touched.

Everything Linda told us, and the letter that came back

It took her about five minutes. Almost all of it was tapping. She typed one thing, the time she wishes she could take back, and she did not have to. Every fact in her letter comes from what she told us. Nothing about her family was made up.


What she tapped

One question to a screen, with big buttons. Each button stands for a plain sentence in her voice. These are hers.

  • I am writing to my daughter.
  • It has been between one and three years since we last spoke.
  • My daughter was the one who stopped the contact.
  • The break was mostly about how my daughter lives her life.
  • I have tried to reach my daughter many times since.
  • When I reached out, there was no reply.
  • There is nothing legal in place about contact between us.
  • My daughter has never said that something I did hurt her badly, or that being with me was not safe.
  • There are grandchildren.
  • There is no money between us.
  • I have blamed someone close to my daughter for this.
  • What I want most from this letter is to explain my side.
  • I miss her laugh.
  • I miss being part of her everyday life.
  • She told me I never listened to her.
  • She told me I criticized her too much.
  • Looking back, I would listen more and argue less.
  • Looking back, I would keep my opinions to myself.
  • What is different now is that I listen more than I talk.
  • What is different now is that I have had time to see my part in this.
  • I love you, and I'm sorry.
  • My daughter calls me Mom.
  • If I send this and hear nothing back, I can let it be, with no follow-up.

She was also asked whether her daughter had told her, in the last three months, not to make contact. She tapped no. A recent request, anything legal, or not being able to let a silence be would each have stopped the letter before she was asked to pay.

What she was shown, free

Before she typed a word, her first answers were turned into three things parents in her situation most often get wrong in a letter. For Linda they were:

  1. Letting someone else into the letter.

  2. Going back over the argument.

  3. Explaining your side.

The one thing she typed

Typed on her phone, exactly as they appear here. Two sentences or so was enough for each.

  1. Is there one time you wish you could take back? Where were you, and what happened?

    “Thanksgiving two years ago, in her kitchen, she asked me to drop it and I said one more thing anyway.”

On the last screen she was asked what her daughter calls her, and wrote “Mom”. The letter is signed with it. She also chose to give the name her letter opens with. We never ask for it: leave it blank and the letter opens “Dear ____,” for you to write in by hand.


The letter

Every sentence comes from something above. It answers what her daughter said, owns one specific thing, asks for nothing, and ends on Linda’s own sentence.

Dear Emily, Your text said every conversation ends with you feeling judged, and that I've never once just listened. You're right. Thanksgiving two years ago, in your kitchen, you asked me to drop it and I said one more thing anyway. Any time I walked into that house I found something to fix, and I said it in front of whoever was standing there. I've stopped giving advice nobody asked for. I still have the thought. I just keep it to myself now. After this letter there will be nothing more. I'm not asking you for anything, and I won't chase you. If you never answer this, I won't hold it against you. Whatever else you remember, I want you to know I loved you more than I knew how to show it, and I'm sorry I made you carry that. Mom

142 words.


What was left out, and why

These are Linda’s own words, typed or tapped, quoted back exactly. Every one of them was true. Each one would have cost her the letter.

  1. “What I want most from this letter is to explain my side.”

    An explanation asks her to weigh your case, so the letter owns one thing you did and explains nothing.

  2. “The break was mostly about how my daughter lives her life.”

    Raising how she lives, even to say it no longer matters to you, would make the letter one more round of the argument.

  3. “I have blamed someone close to my daughter for this.”

    You told us this so that person could stay out of the letter, and nobody close to her appears in it.

  4. “There are grandchildren.”

    She would read any mention of them as the real reason you wrote, so the letter does not mention them at all.

  5. “I have tried to reach my daughter many times since.”

    A count of your tries reads to her as keeping score, so the letter leaves them out and says only what happens from here.


How Emily might respond

This part is optional, and it is not Emily. It is the program’s careful guess at her, written from Linda’s answers and her letter, so that the first hard reply Linda read was not the real one.

Mom, I read this twice. You put my text in front of you and didn't argue with it. That has not happened before. The Thanksgiving part is how I remember it: I asked you to drop it and you said one more thing, with people standing right there. I'm not going to pretend one letter undoes two years. You say you still have the thought and you keep it to yourself now. That's honest. It's also the thing I braced for any time you walked into my house, so I don't know what to do with it yet. You say there will be nothing more after this. I'll know that's true when it has been true for a while. I'm not answering with a plan. I needed to read this without you waiting on the other end of it.

What landed

Her own words, and then "You're right" with nothing after it. The Thanksgiving lines land for the same reason: they say what happened in her kitchen and they do not explain it.

What Emily would push back on

She'd push back on "I still have the thought": she'd hear the same judgment still sitting there, only quieter, and wonder how long you can keep it to yourself.

One line to reconsider

"After this letter there will be nothing more." It is the one promise in the letter she can check. It only lands if it stays true, so be sure you mean it before you send it.

After that comes a plan for sending it: by hand and by mail if she has an address, what to leave out of the envelope, and the ninety days after, in which she sends nothing more.


Begin your own

The questions are free, and they take about five minutes. They will tell you if now is not the time. The letter is $29, one payment, and you are only asked to pay once you know a letter can be written.

Are you writing to your son or your daughter?

We never ask for your child's name.

See what the $29 covers

An example letter | First Letter